Mon June 25, 2012
FBI Checking 100 Suspected Extremists In Military
Originally published on Tue June 26, 2012 5:27 pm
The FBI has conducted more than 100 investigations into suspected Islamic extremists within the military, NPR has learned. About a dozen of those cases are considered serious.
Officials define that as a case requiring a formal investigation to gather information against suspects who appear to have demonstrated a strong intent to attack military targets. This is the first time the figures have been publicly disclosed.
The FBI and Department of Defense call these cases "insider threats." They include not just active and reserve military personnel but also individuals who have access to military facilities such as contractors and close family members with dependent ID cards.
Officials would not provide details about the cases and the FBI would not confirm the numbers, but they did say that cases seen as serious could include, among others things, suspects who seem to be planning an attack or were in touch with "dangerous individuals" who were goading them to attack.
Details Revealed At Closed Congressional Hearing
The FBI and the Department of Defense declined to discuss the figures on the record, but three sources with direct knowledge confirmed that the numbers were revealed in a closed session of a House-Senate committee hearing in December. The FBI also declined to say whether it has compiled more up-to-date figures since that time.
"I was surprised and struck by the numbers; they were larger than I expected," Sen. Joseph Lieberman, an independent from Connecticut and chairman of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security, told NPR. He stopped short of confirming the numbers.
"I know one can say that as a percentage of the millions of people in active military service or working with contractors, the numbers you talk about are a small percentage of the total, but the reality is it only took one man, Nidal Hasan, to kill 13 people at Fort Hood and injure a lot more," Lieberman said.
Hasan was an Army major at Fort Hood in Texas who is charged with opening fire on soldiers in the base's processing center in November 2009. The rampage is considered the most serious terrorist attack on U.S. soil since the Sept. 11 attacks.
Prosecutors say Hasan had been in touch with an American-born radical imam, Anwar al-Awlaki, to ask for spiritual guidance ahead of the shooting; and Awlaki is said to have blessed it. Awlaki was killed in a drone attack in Yemen last year.
Investigators also say Hasan had been displaying signs of increasing radicalization before the shooting took place, but the behavior had not been properly reported. Hasan's court-martial is set to begin on Aug. 20, and he faces the death penalty.
The FBI compiled its tally of Islamic extremist cases in the military late last year for a joint hearing that Lieberman co-chaired. The hearing was looking at possible threats to military communities inside the United States, and the number of cases was revealed at that time.
About A Dozen Cases Face Full Investigation
The FBI typically divides investigations into three categories: assessment, preliminary investigations, and then full investigations in which agents have enough evidence to justify using all the investigative tools at their disposal. As of last December, there were a dozen cases in that last category.
"This number speaks not only to the reality that there is a problem of violent Islamic extremists in the military, but also that the Department of Defense and the FBI since the Nidal Hassan case are working much more closely together," said Lieberman.
Officials stressed that the FBI and the Department of Defense track all kinds of extremism within the military community from white supremacists to neo-Nazis, not just Islamic extremists.
But the Fort Hood shooting inspired new reporting procedures aimed at catching plots before they unfold. Since 2001, law enforcement officials have foiled and prosecuted more than 30 plots or attacks against military targets within the United States.
A Conviction Last Month
Just last month, an AWOL Muslim soldier named Naser Abdo was convicted of plotting to attack Fort Hood. Officers found components for an explosive device in Abdo's hotel room not far from the base.
Abdo told the judge that the plot was supposed to exact some "justice" for the people of Afghanistan and Iraq. In an audio recording played during the trial, Abdo said his Islamic faith was part of the reason he planned the attack.
Lieberman says that Abdo actually called out Major Hasan's name shortly after he was found guilty of conspiring to attack a restaurant just outside Fort Hood where active service members often went with their families. Abdo is expected to be sentenced in July. It is not clear whether his case was one of the cases on the FBI's list.
Military Bases Considered Likely Targets
Officials say for many aspiring violent jihadis a military base is seen as fair game for an attack. Al-Qaida's narrative revolves around the idea that America is at war with Islam the world over, and the perception is that the U.S. military is at the forefront of that battle.
Counterterrorism officials say that for many freshly minted jihadists, a military target is an easier choice and easier to justify than targeting a shopping mall or other soft civilian targets — precisely because it is seen as part and parcel of the battle.
"After the Fort Hood shooting, having just one serious case, much less having a dozen, is cause for concern," says Bruce Hoffman, a professor and counterterrorism expert at Georgetown University and a distinguished scholar at the Wilson Center.
"You have to think about how people in the military community aren't just your run-of-the-mill jihadis," Hoffman says. "These are people who have access to guns and to bases and are supposed to have security clearances. This is not the community you want to be radicalizing."
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Audie Cornish.
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
And I'm Melissa Block. We begin this hour with an exclusive story about alleged threats from within the U.S. military. NPR has learned that the FBI conducted more than 100 investigations into suspected Islamic extremists inside the military, and at least a dozen of those cases are considered serious - serious enough to warrant a deeper inquiry.
This is the first time these numbers have been revealed publically. NPR's Dina Temple-Raston joins me with more on the story. And Dina, what have you learned.
DINA TEMPLE-RASTON, BYLINE: Well, what we know is that at the end of last year, the FBI provided a handful of lawmakers with an accounting of all the active Islamic extremist cases they were pursuing inside the military community. And this happened during a closed session in December that was called to look at threats to the military here at home. And that's when lawmakers first heard that the FBI and the Department of Defense had about 100 cases, and that a dozen of them were considered serious.
You know, the FBI declined to confirm the numbers for us because they said they're classified, but the officials familiar with the tally confirmed that the numbers we have are correct. What we don't know is if those numbers have changed dramatically since December.
BLOCK: And Dina, specifically, these are cases in which the FBI and the Pentagon were worried that somebody inside the military was actually going to attack a military target?
TEMPLE-RASTON: Exactly right. I mean, the universe of people is more than just active military and reservists. It also includes close family members and contractors, basically anyone who can get onto a military installation by showing a military ID. Now, if you think about that, that's hundreds of thousands of people that could be included in that universe.
And you could say that 100 cases is just a tiny percentage of that. But Senator Joseph Lieberman, who co-chaired that joint hearing last December, told us that that wasn't the only way to think about it.
SENATOR JOSEPH LIEBERMAN: But the reality is, it only took one man, Nidal Hasan, to kill 13 people at Fort Hood and injure a lot more. So I thought the number was higher than I would have guessed.
TEMPLE-RASTON: Now, the man he's referring to, Nidal Hasan, that's Major Nidal Hasan. He was an active-duty Army psychiatrist who opened fire on soldiers at a processing center at Fort Hood in 2009. Counterterrorism officials considered that to be the worst terrorist attack on the homeland since 9/11.
BLOCK: And Dina, these investigations that you're talking about, are they a reaction to that mass shooting at Fort Hood? Did these stem from that, specifically?
TEMPLE-RASTON: To a certain extent, they are. Both the FBI and the Defense Department have been extra vigilant in tracking these cases since Fort Hood, and there have been - there had been a bunch of warning signs that indicated that Major Hasan was becoming increasingly radicalized. And people like Senator Lieberman think officials at the time may have turned a blind eye to them.
And since Fort Hood, the presumption is to treat these things much more seriously.
BLOCK: Now, Dina, we mentioned there were maybe 100 or so investigations into suspected Islamic extremists, but that narrowed way down to those that were considered a possibly serious threat. Any way to judge how serious these threats might be?
TEMPLE-RASTON: Well, it's difficult to say. I mean, there's always a chance that there has been some overreaction. I mean, the military and the FBI have been really wary of looking like they're only going after Muslims. Officials that we talked to stressed that the FBI and the military track all kinds of extremism in the ranks, from white supremacists to neo-Nazis.
And it's also hard to gauge how serious these cases are, because as a general matter, the FBI doesn't discuss open investigations, which is what all of these would be. But everybody I talked to said that after Fort Hood, there was new vigilance to not allow an attack like that to happen again. Among other things, the FBI and the Defense Department set up a new reporting procedure to make sure that someone like Hasan wouldn't fall through the cracks.
And the FBI wouldn't say how close any of these cases are to becoming something like a Hasan case or a Fort Hood case, or how close they are to arrests. And until something like that happens and we could see the evidence, it's hard to gauge what kind of threat this really is.
BLOCK: That's NPR's Dina Temple-Raston with an exclusive report on FBI investigations into possible Islamic extremists within the U.S. military. Dina, thank you.
TEMPLE-RASTON: You're very welcome. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.